Skip to content
JACK & TORQUE

Comparison

Arcan vs Daytona Floor Jack

Our default pick against the jack most people compare it to. One of them publishes a standards claim, and it is not the expensive one.

By Ryder M. · Published November 5, 2026 · Last reviewed November 5, 2026

We earn a commission when you buy through the Amazon links on this page, at no extra cost to you. It never changes which tool we put first, and we publish no price we have not verified. How this site is funded.

Arcan vs Daytona Floor Jack — ranked picks with scores and a price check for each
#PickCapacityScorePrice
1
Arcan A20019 3-Ton Aluminum Low-Profile Floor Jack, Amazon product photo
Arcan A20019 3-Ton Aluminum Low-Profile Floor JackThe aluminum case
3 ton (6,000 lb)9.0
2
Sunex 66035HR Skyhawk 3.5-Ton High Reach Floor Jack, Amazon product photo
Sunex 66035HR Skyhawk 3.5-Ton High Reach Floor JackIf the standards claim is what convinced you
3.5 ton8.8
3
BIG RED T83006 3-Ton Hydraulic Trolley Jack, Amazon product photo
BIG RED T83006 3-Ton Hydraulic Trolley JackIf price was the real reason
3 ton (6,000 lb)8.5

Product photographs come from each product's own Amazon listing via the Associates program. They are the seller's images, not photographs of anything we own — we have no test rig and claim none.

Arcan A20019 3-Ton Aluminum Low-Profile Floor Jack, Amazon product photo

Short answer: on published figures the DAYTONA DS300LP is the better jack, and it is the cheaper one. It starts lower (3-1/8 in against 3.75 in), finishes higher (19-7/8 in against 18 in) and its listing carries a line Arcan's does not: "Complies with ASME-PASE standards." The Arcan A20019 wins on exactly two things, and whether they are worth the premium is a question about you rather than about the jacks — it weighs 23 lb less, and it arrives at your house.

The published figures, side by side

Every number below comes from the maker's own page, linked at the foot of this comparison. Neither jack has been in our hands; we do not run a lab, and how we review says so.

Arcan A20019 and Harbor Freight DAYTONA DS300LP (item 64240), as published by each maker
SpecificationArcan A20019DAYTONA DS300LP (64240)
Capacity3 ton (6,000 lb)3 ton (6,000 lb working load)
Minimum height3.75 in3-1/8 in
Maximum height18 in19-7/8 in
Weight56 lb79 lb
MaterialAircraft-grade aluminumSteel
StandardsNo PASE statement published"Complies with ASME-PASE standards"
Overload protectionBypass and overload valves publishedNot stated on the listing
Warranty1 year90 days
How you buy itDeliveredHarbor Freight, oversized item
Arcan A20019 and Harbor Freight DAYTONA DS300LP (item 64240), as published by each maker

Two of those rows will decide this for most people, and they are not the two anybody argues about online. The capacity figures are identical and neither is the limit on a car corner anyway — our capacity guide works through why 2 ton is already more than a sedan puts on a jack. What actually differs is 1.6 in of range and 23 lb of mass.

Where the Daytona wins, and it is not close

It goes lower and higher. 3-1/8 in at rest is low enough for most unmodified cars, and 19-7/8 in at full extension clears a wheel on a crossover with room to spare for the stands. That is a genuinely wider working window than the Arcan's 3.75 in to 18 in, at both ends of the stroke.

It publishes a standards claim. Harbor Freight's certification field on this listing reads "Complies with ASME-PASE standards". ASME PASE is the US safety standard for portable automotive service equipment — a named document with a defined test regime, not an adjective — and a company that prints that line is making a checkable assertion rather than a marketing one. Arcan does not publish an equivalent statement for the A20019. We treat that gap the same way our safest floor jacks page does: named compliance beats a described mechanism, which beats an adjective.

It costs less. Harbor Freight publishes the price on its own listing and it undercuts the Arcan comfortably. We do not print other retailers' prices here — the live figure on this page is the current Amazon price for the jacks we link — but the gap is large enough that it belongs in the decision.

Where the Arcan earns the premium

23 lb. 56 lb against 79 lb is a 29% difference, and it is the whole argument for aluminum. It is the difference between a jack you slide out with one hand and one you plant in a corner and leave there; between a jack that goes in the trunk for a track day or a friend's driveway and one that does not. If you have a flight of steps between your car and wherever the jack lives, this row is the only one that matters. Aluminum vs steel floor jacks is the longer version of this trade.

A year against 90 days. Arcan backs the A20019 for 1 year; Harbor Freight's listing guarantees this jack free from defects in materials and workmanship for 90 days from purchase. For a hydraulic tool that is a meaningful difference, because the failure people actually see — a jack that will not hold height, or seeps past a seal — tends to show up after a few months of use rather than in the first fortnight.

It publishes its overload protection. Arcan states bypass and overload valves on the specification page. Harbor Freight's listing for the 64240 does not mention a safety or overload valve at all. That is not a claim the Daytona lacks one — PASE compliance itself implies overload testing, and Harbor Freight's own owner's manuals for its other jacks discuss the safety valve explicitly. It is a note about what each page will stand behind in writing.

You can have it delivered. The Daytona is a Harbor Freight exclusive, flagged oversized on its listing and not shippable to Alaska or Hawaii. If there is no store within a sensible drive, the comparison ends there regardless of the specifications.

What neither listing tells you

Three things we would want before calling either jack the better tool, and neither maker publishes:

The short version

  • Service parts. Neither page publishes a seal kit or a parts diagram. On a hydraulic jack that is the difference between a repair and a replacement after a few years.
  • Saddle diameter. Arcan publishes a 4 in saddle elsewhere in its range and the Daytona listing gives no saddle figure at all, which matters when you are aiming at a pinch weld rather than a frame rail.
  • Pump strokes to full height. Both jacks are sold on how quickly they rise, and neither publishes a figure you could compare.

That is the normal state of this category rather than a complaint about these two companies. It is also why we rank on the handful of specifications that are published consistently — capacity, the two height numbers, weight, material and whatever standards line a maker is willing to print.

Which should you buy?

Buy the Daytona if there is a Harbor Freight you can get to, the jack will live in one garage, and you would rather have the wider lift range and the published PASE line than the lighter chassis. On the numbers, that is the stronger jack for less money, and we would rather say so than steer you to the option we can earn a commission on.

Buy the Arcan A20019 if you will be moving the jack — between cars, into a trunk, up or down steps — or if a 1-year warranty and a published overload valve are worth more to you than 1.6 in of range, or if there is simply no Harbor Freight near you. It is still our default pick in best floor jacks, and the reason is the one above rather than anything about capacity.

Buy neither if you only ever intend to do oil changes on a car with normal ride height. Ramps are cheaper, faster and have no hydraulics to fail — floor jack vs ramps covers when that swap is the right call, and Pittsburgh vs Daytona compares the Daytona against the cheaper jack on the same shelf if Harbor Freight is where you are shopping anyway.

The picks in full

Every pick, in detail

Arcan A20019 3-Ton Aluminum Low-Profile Floor Jack, Amazon product photo

1. The aluminum case

Arcan A20019 3-Ton Aluminum Low-Profile Floor Jack

Arcan · score 9.0/10

A 3-ton aluminum service jack that slides under a stock sedan at 3.75 in and still reaches 18 in — the widest useful range a beginner can buy at one weight they can actually move.

Arcan publishes 3.75 in to 18 in of lift, 56 lb of aircraft-grade aluminum, a 1-year warranty and — a detail worth having in writing — bypass and overload valves. Everything you pay extra for here is about handling the jack rather than lifting the car: 23 lb less to drag across a garage, lift into a trunk or carry down steps, and a box that arrives at your door. Against it: Arcan publishes no ASME PASE compliance statement for this model, the Daytona below starts lower and finishes higher, and it is the most expensive way on this page to buy 3 tons of capacity.

Published specifications

Capacity
3 ton (6,000 lb) Arcan Professional Tools
Min saddle height
3.75 in Arcan Professional Tools
Max lift height
18 in Arcan Professional Tools
Material
Aircraft-grade aluminum Arcan Professional Tools

What works

  • Fits under most unmodified sedans without ramps or boards
  • 18 in of lift clears a wheel on a crossover, not just a car
  • Aluminum keeps it at a weight one person can lift into a trunk

What you give up

  • Costs noticeably more than a steel jack of the same capacity
  • Arcan does not publish an ASME PASE compliance statement for this model
  • 56 lb is light for the class, not light in absolute terms

Our scoring

  • Fit & reach9.4
  • Safety margin8.8
  • Beginner ease9.0
  • Build quality8.8
  • Value8.0
$256.00 · View on Amazon

$326.00 21% off

#ad Price as of November 16, 2026. How this is funded

Specifications published by Arcan — we earn nothing from that link.

Sunex 66035HR Skyhawk 3.5-Ton High Reach Floor Jack, Amazon product photo

2. If the standards claim is what convinced you

Sunex 66035HR Skyhawk 3.5-Ton High Reach Floor Jack

Sunex Tools · score 8.8/10

24.4 in of lift from a 3.58 in start — the longest reach of any jack on this site, and the only one here whose maker states ASME PASE compliance outright.

The reason to read this row: if the Daytona's "Complies with ASME-PASE standards" line is what pulled you toward it, this is the one jack in our registry whose maker states PASE compliance outright on its own product page — and you can have it delivered rather than driving to a store. Sunex publishes 3.58 in to 24.4 in, an 18 in extended chassis and a 4.6 in saddle, so it also beats both jacks in this comparison on reach at both ends. Against it: it is 3.5 ton and built like it, it costs more than either jack above, and that much lift is more than a stock sedan will ever ask for.

Published specifications

Capacity
3.5 ton Sunex Tools
Min height
3.58 in Sunex Tools
Max height
24.4 in Sunex Tools
Chassis
18 in extended chassis Sunex Tools
Saddle
4.6 in oversized saddle Sunex Tools
Standards
ASME PASE compliant Sunex Tools

What works

  • 24.4 in of lift reaches a lifted truck's frame rail, which almost nothing else here does
  • 3.58 in minimum means the high reach costs you nothing at the low end
  • Sunex states ASME PASE compliance, which most jack makers do not

What you give up

  • A 50 in handle and an extended chassis need a real garage bay, not a carport corner
  • Far more jack than a sedan owner will ever use
  • Sunex does not publish a net weight for this model

Our scoring

  • Fit & reach9.2
  • Safety margin8.8
  • Beginner ease8.0
  • Build quality9.2
  • Value7.4
$379.99 · View on Amazon

#ad Price as of November 16, 2026. How this is funded

Specifications published by Sunex Tools — we earn nothing from that link.

BIG RED T83006 3-Ton Hydraulic Trolley Jack, Amazon product photo

3. If price was the real reason

BIG RED T83006 3-Ton Hydraulic Trolley Jack

Torin (BIG RED) · score 8.5/10

Reaches 20-7/8 in, which is the number that matters if your vehicle sits high — but its 5-7/8 in minimum means it will not slide under a low car.

If what attracted you to the Daytona was the number on the shelf edge rather than the compliance line, this is the honest comparison: a steel trolley jack at a fraction of the aluminum money, 5-7/8 in to 20-7/8 in, with a safety bypass system Torin states for overload. It will not go under a lowered car — that 5-7/8 in start is the trade — but on a crossover, a truck or any car with normal ride height it does the same job as both jacks above. Against it: steel and heavy, the highest start height here, and no published standards compliance statement.

Published specifications

Capacity
3 ton (6,000 lb) Torin
Lift range
5-7/8 in – 20-7/8 in Torin
Material
Steel Torin
Handle length
24.5 in Torin
Overload protection
Safety bypass system Torin

What works

  • 20-7/8 in of lift handles pickup and SUV ride heights
  • Extra-long saddle neck saves pumping on tall vehicles
  • Steel construction at a price most first-time buyers will accept

What you give up

  • 5-7/8 in minimum height rules out most low cars
  • Heavier to move around than an aluminum jack of the same capacity
  • Single-piston pump means more strokes than a dual-piston jack

Our scoring

  • Fit & reach8.2
  • Safety margin8.6
  • Beginner ease8.4
  • Build quality8.2
  • Value9.0
$89.90 · View on Amazon

#ad Price as of November 16, 2026. How this is funded

Specifications published by Torin (BIG RED) — we earn nothing from that link.

Method

How these picks were chosen

We did not test these tools. We do not run a laboratory, we have not loaded a jack to failure or checked a wrench on a calibration bench, and we will not tell you otherwise. What we did instead is read the published manufacturer specifications, check the figures that matter against the safety standard that applies to portable automotive lifting equipment, and work out which tool suits which job. Every number on this page links to where it came from, so you can check us.

The five things we score are the five that decide a first purchase: will it fit under and lift your car, how much safety margin the rating and the locking mechanism leave you, how hard it is to get right alone in a driveway, what the materials and published standards say about how long it lasts, and what the money buys against the rest of the field.

Read the full method — including how we pick a top pick, and how prices get on the page.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

+Is the Arcan A20019 worth the extra money over a Daytona?

Only for the weight and the warranty. The Daytona DS300LP starts lower (3-1/8 in against 3.75 in), lifts higher (19-7/8 in against 18 in), publishes an ASME-PASE compliance line Arcan does not, and costs less. What the Arcan buys is 23 lb less to move — 56 lb against 79 lb — a 1-year warranty instead of 90 days, published bypass and overload valves, and delivery to your door.

+Does Arcan publish ASME PASE compliance?

Not for the A20019. Its specification page lists capacity, heights, weight, material and a 1-year warranty, and states bypass and overload valves, but carries no PASE statement. Harbor Freight's listing for the DAYTONA 64240 does carry one. The only jack in our registry whose maker states PASE compliance outright and that you can have delivered is the Sunex 66035HR.

+Which is the better jack for a low car?

The Daytona, on published figures: 3-1/8 in at rest against the Arcan's 3.75 in. Neither is low enough for a genuinely lowered car, where you are into ramps or a lift pad first — low profile floor jacks covers the field at that end.

+Is a 90-day warranty normal for a floor jack?

It is short for the category. Harbor Freight guarantees the 64240 against defects in materials and workmanship for 90 days from purchase; Arcan backs the A20019 for a year. Read the warranty as a specification rather than as paperwork — on a hydraulic tool it tells you how long the maker expects the seals to be its problem.

+Is aluminum or steel better in a floor jack?

Neither is stronger in any way that matters at 3 ton — both jacks here are rated 6,000 lb. Aluminum is lighter and costs more; steel is heavier and cheaper, and usually buys you more lift range for the money. Choose on whether the jack moves.

Sources

Where these figures come from

Read next

Related reading